Charlie’s water bottle – the recycling debate continues – Story – Campbell Live – TV Shows – 3 News

Posted on May 9, 2012 by DrRossH in BioPlastics

Charlie’s water bottle – the recycling debate continues – Story – Campbell Live – TV Shows – 3 News.

The media did an accurate story on this product and concluded to the firm disagreement of the bottler, that this Charlies bottle is not recyclable in NZ with the current infrastructure and it has to go to a landfill.

Even though the bottle is covered with green labelling terms, like Eco Bottle, recyclable, Honest Water and more, the simple truth is that at this time, this is a bioplastic that cannot be mixed with other plastics and it has to go to landfills.  Until such time as the whole infrastructure of plastic waste recycling is changed to accommodate bioplastics, then bioplastics are going to go to landfills and they are more of a problem than simple conventional bottles who can be easily recycled.

Not that ‘Can’ be recycled does mean ‘Are’ recycled.  In most places bottle recycling is about 20-30% at most, many are littered on the ground and the rest dumped in trash bins (even though there may be a recycle bin 1 m away) to go to a landfill.  In localities where there is a container deposit scheme then recycling rates are in excess of 80%.

The is increasing discussion about EPR or Extended Producer Responsibility.  Under EPR the manufacturers are in part responsible for the plastic waste their products are making.  This could be in the form of bottle recycling schemes, extensive advertising campaigns to educate the people that this plastic waste has value for the economy if recycled and so it should not be trashed, or the supply of a lot more recycling bins and arranging for their collection and other ideas.

In this case the company Charlies wants the government (us) and consumers to foot the bill for the management of the incompatible plastic waste their products are causing.   They are the ones who need to start this EPR, they could put a deposit refund on their bottles, though it would be unlikely to work for such a small percentage of bottles, they could relabel their bottles to tell consumers they have to take their bottles to a commercial compost facility for the ‘eco’ claim to be achieved.

Let’s not forget they are selling water at an estimated 2000 times the price people can get from a water tap.  Consumers need to be educated to be smarter to not buy into this  green washing and feeling they need to buy bottle water too.  Review this video for a great fun expose on bottled water.