In One’s Cups – Going Green

Posted on April 14, 2012 by DrRossH in BioPlastics, Landfills and Disposal, Plastic Waste News

In One’s Cups – Going Green.

There are many inaccuracies in this article that if not bought out can misinform a reader of the actual process.

1) The word Biodegradable at the consumer level is horribly misused.  it comes down to where the biodegradation process is engineered to happen by the manufacturer.   There is;

a) compost biodegradable where a product will only biodegrade in commercial composting conditions.  Plenty of oxygen, temps above 60 deg C and moisture.   Not home compost piles.   Even then many composters will not take compostable plastic as they clog up their processes.  Commercial compost facilities are few and far between and there is no special collection of compostable plastics, so this renders the concept of compostable plastics not a user friendly option.

b) There are landfill biodegradable additives that when added to plastics they will biodegrade in a landfill with moisture.  This can be with or with or without oxygen present. (See www.goecopure.com for an example). 

c) There is oxodegradable additives which is not biological but a chemical reaction that causes the plastic in the presence of oxygen to fragment into little pieces.   This is actually worse for the environment.  This is what the author is confused about, but is correct they will not break down in a landfill due to lack of oxygen.

2) Compostable plastics biodegrade to CO2 and any energy that was stored in the plastic is lost in the biodegradation process.

3) Landfill biodegradable plastics when biodegrading in a landfill without oxygen present produce methane, CH4.  This gas can be captured to combusted to produce energy or Electricity.  i.e. the energy in the plastic is recovered.

4) Oxodegradable plastics do nothing but make lots of little plastic bits that get into the water ways and our environment.  That is not what we want.

 

Recycling is what we should do first.  But if every piece of disposable plastic was made with a landfill biodegradable additive in it, then if the item was recycled 10 times before it became unusable for some reason and it was sent to a landfill, then it would break down.  For those modern landfills that capture the methane, we would get its energy back.   We call this the BACKSTOP method for plastics as no matter if the item is recycled or landfilled, either way the plastic item is gone and not sitting as plastic waste for the next 300 years.   Why should our future generations deal with our plastic waste that we used just because it provided us a few minutes of convenience for us to use?