Philadelphia sues Bimbo, S.C. Johnson over ‘recyclable’ claims on plastic bags – USA

Posted on October 1, 2025 by DrRossH in Plastic Recycling

The City of Philadelphia has filed suit against Bimbo Bakeries and S.C. Johnson, alleging the companies misled consumers by labeling plastic bread bags and Ziploc storage bags as recyclable when they usually end up as waste.

Source: Philadelphia sues Bimbo, S.C. Johnson over ‘recyclable’ claims on plastic bags | Plastics News

The city of Philadelphia is taking two major consumer brands to court, saying their plastic packaging isn’t nearly as recyclable as the labels suggest.

On Sept. 24, the city filed suit against Bimbo Bakeries USA — the maker of brands such as Thomas’ and Sara Lee — and S.C. Johnson & Son Inc., owner of Ziploc, in Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas.

The lawsuit argues that the companies misled shoppers by using recycling symbols and instructions that make plastic bread bags and storage bags look like they can go in curbside bins.

City officials say that’s not true. Most of those bags are made from thin plastic film, often low density polyethylene, which clogs recycling equipment and usually ends up in landfills or incinerators even when consumers try to recycle them.

“Companies that label their products with the goal of implying their product is recyclable when it isn’t are not just breaking the law, but they are violating public trust and contributing to waste,” Mayor Cherelle L. Parker said in a statement.

Philadelphia wants the companies to change their labeling, pay fines of up to $2,000 for each violation, and cover the extra costs the city says it faces when plastic bags contaminate its recycling stream.

The lawsuit alleges that while plastic film is technically recyclable, in reality there’s little infrastructure to handle it and recycling plants struggle when the thin bags jam machinery.

The complaint also cited investigations by ABC News and Bloomberg that have shown that store drop-off programs often don’t keep the bags out of landfills.

City Solicitor Renee Garcia said the lawsuit is about honesty as much as waste. “Companies like Bimbo and S.C. Johnson have manipulated the good intentions of shoppers,” she said.